Plysight

Articles

The openings that win at your rating: 177,000 games, scored

Which opening scores best depends on your rating. We scored 177,000 online games between evenly matched players, each opening for the side that chose it. Between 800 and 1599, two answers to 1.e4, the Caro-Kann and the Sicilian, score 54% to 55% for Black. That's more than White scores on average, 52%. By 2000 the edge has mostly gone: 50% and 48%, against Black's usual 48%.

How we counted

In classical games

Classical is slower chess, so it comes first, though the sample is smaller: 4,267 games, every rating together. With 100 to 300 games, a score can move a few points either way.

In classical, the Sicilian scores best for Black; the Philidor worst.

Classical games: each opening's score for the side that chose it, against that side's score in every gameWhite's openingsevery game 51%Ruy LopezRuy Lopez: 58% for White58%Queen's GambitQueen's Gambit: 55% for White55%EnglishEnglish: 53% for White53%ItalianItalian: 53% for White53%London SystemLondon System: 52% for White52%ScotchScotch: 51% for White51%RétiRéti: 47% for White47%Black's defensesevery game 49%SicilianSicilian: 55% for Black55%Caro-KannCaro-Kann: 53% for Black53%FrenchFrench: 52% for Black52%ScandinavianScandinavian: 48% for Black48%Queen's Gambit DeclinedQueen's Gambit Declined: 46% for Black46%Petrov'sPetrov's: 44% for Black44%PhilidorPhilidor: 36% for Black36%
Score for the side that chose the opening, every rating together. Rust: below that side's score in every game.Classical games on Lichess, August 2026, between players rated within 100 points; openings with 100 games or more.
OpeningForScoreGames
Ruy LopezWhite58%162
Queen's GambitWhite55%256
English OpeningWhite53%140
Italian GameWhite53%311
London SystemWhite52%163
Scotch GameWhite51%114
Réti OpeningWhite47%113
Every gameWhite51%4,267
Sicilian DefenseBlack55%472
Caro-Kann DefenseBlack53%258
French DefenseBlack52%241
Scandinavian DefenseBlack48%170
Queen's Gambit DeclinedBlack46%135
Petrov's DefenseBlack44%105
Philidor DefenseBlack36%112
Every gameBlack49%4,267

The faster games below, with forty times as many games, show the same ends: the Sicilian near the top for Black, the Philidor at the bottom.

The best openings for White

White's openings: most score above White's average

White's openings: most score above White's average: score by rating group, one dot per groupViennaVienna, 800–1199: 58%Vienna, 1200–1599: 56%Vienna, 1600–1999: 54%ScotchScotch, 800–1199: 56%Scotch, 1200–1599: 59%Scotch, 1600–1999: 54%Scotch, 2000+: 54%Queen's GambitQueen's Gambit, 800–1199: 54%Queen's Gambit, 1200–1599: 58%Queen's Gambit, 1600–1999: 55%Queen's Gambit, 2000+: 54%Ruy LopezRuy Lopez, 800–1199: 53%Ruy Lopez, 1200–1599: 55%Ruy Lopez, 1600–1999: 55%Ruy Lopez, 2000+: 55%London SystemLondon System, 800–1199: 55%London System, 1200–1599: 55%London System, 1600–1999: 52%London System, 2000+: 54%EnglishEnglish, 800–1199: 52%English, 1200–1599: 54%English, 1600–1999: 54%English, 2000+: 53%RétiRéti, 800–1199: 51%Réti, 1200–1599: 53%Réti, 1600–1999: 56%Réti, 2000+: 54%ItalianItalian, 800–1199: 53%Italian, 1200–1599: 53%Italian, 1600–1999: 51%Italian, 2000+: 51%King's GambitKing's Gambit, 800–1199: 52%King's Gambit, 1200–1599: 53%King's Gambit, 1600–1999: 49%Bishop'sBishop's, 800–1199: 47%Bishop's, 1200–1599: 49%Bishop's, 1600–1999: 50%Bishop's, 2000+: 52%40%50%60%every game 52%

800–11991200–15991600–19992000+

Score for White, by rating group. The dashed line is White's score in every game.Rapid and blitz games on Lichess, August 2026, between players rated within 100 points.
Rapid and blitz, score for White800–11991200–15991600–19992000+Games
Every game52%52%51%52%173,139
1.e452%51%51%52%105,966
1.d453%54%52%54%46,111
Vienna Game58%56%54%–2,335
Scotch Game56%59%54%54%4,461
Queen's Gambit54%58%55%54%10,159
Ruy Lopez53%55%55%55%4,318
London System55%55%52%54%7,639
English Opening52%54%54%53%5,556
Réti Opening51%53%56%54%4,514
Italian Game53%53%51%51%9,698
King's Gambit52%53%49%–2,081
Bishop's Opening47%49%50%52%3,285

1.d4 scores more than 1.e4 at every rating from 800 up: 52% to 54%, against 51% to 52%. Below 1600 the Vienna and the Scotch score highest, 56% to 59%, with the Queen's Gambit close behind. The Bishop's Opening is the one common choice below White's average at every rating under 2000. A dash means fewer than 200 games.

The best answers to 1.e4

Against 1.e4, the Caro-Kann and the Sicilian lead until 2000

Against 1.e4, the Caro-Kann and the Sicilian lead until 2000: score by rating group, one dot per groupCaro-KannCaro-Kann, 800–1199: 55%Caro-Kann, 1200–1599: 55%Caro-Kann, 1600–1999: 53%Caro-Kann, 2000+: 50%SicilianSicilian, 800–1199: 55%Sicilian, 1200–1599: 54%Sicilian, 1600–1999: 52%Sicilian, 2000+: 48%PircPirc, 800–1199: 52%Pirc, 1200–1599: 51%Pirc, 1600–1999: 48%Pirc, 2000+: 49%FrenchFrench, 800–1199: 49%French, 1200–1599: 51%French, 1600–1999: 51%French, 2000+: 48%ScandinavianScandinavian, 800–1199: 46%Scandinavian, 1200–1599: 48%Scandinavian, 1600–1999: 47%Scandinavian, 2000+: 49%ModernModern, 800–1199: 47%Modern, 1200–1599: 48%Modern, 1600–1999: 45%Modern, 2000+: 46%1…e51…e5, 800–1199: 47%1…e5, 1200–1599: 46%1…e5, 1600–1999: 47%1…e5, 2000+: 48%Petrov'sPetrov's, 800–1199: 44%Petrov's, 1200–1599: 45%Petrov's, 1600–1999: 47%PhilidorPhilidor, 800–1199: 40%Philidor, 1200–1599: 38%Philidor, 1600–1999: 40%Philidor, 2000+: 45%40%50%60%every game 48%

800–11991200–15991600–19992000+

Score for Black, by rating group. The dashed line is Black's score in every game.Rapid and blitz games on Lichess, August 2026, between players rated within 100 points.
Rapid and blitz, score for Black800–11991200–15991600–19992000+Games
Every game48%48%49%48%173,139
Caro-Kann Defense55%55%53%50%12,827
Sicilian Defense55%54%52%48%20,060
Pirc Defense52%51%48%49%3,747
French Defense49%51%51%48%10,888
Scandinavian Defense46%48%47%49%8,729
Modern Defense47%48%45%46%3,855
1…e5, any47%46%47%48%43,871
Petrov's Defense44%45%47%–2,686
Philidor Defense40%38%40%45%3,886

The Caro-Kann and the Sicilian score 54% to 55% from 800 to 1599, more than White scores on average. Both slide toward Black's usual score as ratings rise. The most common answer, 1…e5, scores at or below Black's average at every rating, 46% to 48%. And the Philidor, 1…e5 2.Nf3 d6, is the lowest-scoring defense here: 38% to 45%.

The best answers to 1.d4

Against 1.d4, no defense scores above Black's average for long

Against 1.d4, no defense scores above Black's average for long: score by rating group, one dot per groupKing's IndianKing's Indian, 1200–1599: 51%King's Indian, 1600–1999: 51%King's Indian, 2000+: 46%Nimzo-IndianNimzo-Indian, 1600–1999: 51%Nimzo-Indian, 2000+: 47%DutchDutch, 1200–1599: 49%Dutch, 1600–1999: 45%Dutch, 2000+: 48%Queen's Gambit DeclinedQueen's Gambit Declined, 800–1199: 48%Queen's Gambit Declined, 1200–1599: 42%Queen's Gambit Declined, 1600–1999: 45%Queen's Gambit Declined, 2000+: 48%SlavSlav, 800–1199: 46%Slav, 1200–1599: 46%Slav, 1600–1999: 46%Slav, 2000+: 44%Englund GambitEnglund Gambit, 800–1199: 47%Englund Gambit, 1200–1599: 48%Englund Gambit, 1600–1999: 45%Queen's Gambit AcceptedQueen's Gambit Accepted, 800–1199: 45%Queen's Gambit Accepted, 1200–1599: 39%Queen's Gambit Accepted, 1600–1999: 44%40%50%60%every game 48%

800–11991200–15991600–19992000+

Score for Black, by rating group. The dashed line is Black's score in every game.Rapid and blitz games on Lichess, August 2026, between players rated within 100 points.
Rapid and blitz, score for Black800–11991200–15991600–19992000+Games
King's Indian Defense–51%51%46%1,831
Nimzo-Indian Defense––51%47%894
Dutch Defense–49%45%48%1,337
Queen's Gambit Declined48%42%45%48%5,163
Slav Defense46%46%46%44%3,004
Englund Gambit47%48%45%–2,405
Queen's Gambit Accepted45%39%44%–1,740

Fewer games, and a flatter picture. The King's Indian scores 51% from 1200 to 1999 and the Nimzo-Indian 51% from 1600 to 1999, above Black's average; both drop below it at 2000+. Taking the pawn in the Queen's Gambit scores lowest: 39% at 1200–1599.

It shows by move 12

Is it the opening, or the players who choose it? One sign it's the opening: the gap is there before the middlegame starts. Among players rated 800 to 1599, White is a pawn or more ahead after move 12 in 40% of all games. Against the Caro-Kann, 28%.

The gap shows by move 12.

Games where White was a pawn or more ahead after move 12, by Black's defense, players rated 800 to 1599Caro-Kann: White a pawn or more ahead in 28%Caro-Kann28%Sicilian: White a pawn or more ahead in 30%Sicilian30%French: White a pawn or more ahead in 35%French35%Every game: White a pawn or more ahead in 40%Every game40%1…e5: White a pawn or more ahead in 45%1…e545%Philidor: White a pawn or more ahead in 48%Philidor48%Queen's Gambit Accepted: White a pawn or more ahead in 58%Queen's Gambit Accepted58%
Games where White was a pawn or more ahead after move 12, players rated 800 to 1599.Rapid and blitz, by Lichess's engine evaluation.
After 12 moves, 800–1599White a pawn or more aheadBlack a pawn or more ahead
Caro-Kann Defense28%25%
Sicilian Defense30%27%
French Defense35%26%
Every game40%24%
1…e5, any45%24%
Philidor Defense48%17%
Queen's Gambit Accepted58%17%

Every one of these openings is sound when it's played well. These numbers say how they go at each level when people play them as they do. Where games go wrong in those first moves, and why below 1600 it's mostly habits rather than theory: Chess openings by rating.

What to play

  1. Below 1600, as Black against 1.e4: the Caro-Kann or the Sicilian. Leave the Philidor alone.
  2. As White: 1.d4 scores a little more at every rating. Below 1600, the Vienna and the Scotch score highest.
  3. From 2000: the defenses to 1.e4 close in on Black's average: they scored 45% to 50%, against 48%. Pick the one whose ideas you understand.

In your report: "Your openings" shows how you come out of each opening you play, next to players at your rating.

Common questions

What is the best chess opening? No single opening scores best at every rating. In 177,000 online games between evenly matched players, 1.d4 scored a little more than 1.e4 for White at every rating from 800 up, and against 1.e4 the Caro-Kann and the Sicilian scored best for Black.

What is the best chess opening for Black? Against 1.e4, the Caro-Kann and the Sicilian: 54% to 55% for Black between 800 and 1599, more than White scores on average. In classical games the Sicilian scored 55%. Against 1.d4, the King's Indian and the Nimzo-Indian scored 51% from 1600 to 1999.

What is the best opening for White? 1.d4 scored 52% to 54% for White across ratings, 1.e4 51% to 52%. Below 1600 the Vienna and the Scotch scored highest, 56% to 59%. In classical games, the Ruy Lopez scored 58%.

Which chess opening scores worst? For Black, the Philidor Defense (1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 d6): 38% to 45% in rapid and blitz and 36% in classical, against Black's usual 48% to 49%. White is a pawn or more ahead after move 12 in 48% of those games below 1600.

About these numbers

See how your openings go. Your last 200 games from chess.com or Lichess, or a PGN file. Free, no account.

Analyze your games